![Screen shot 2012-12-10 at 5.01.48 PM.png](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/Screen%20shot%202012-12-10%20at%205.01.48%20PM.png)
![Screen shot 2012-12-10 at 5.17.46 PM.png](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/Screen%20shot%202012-12-10%20at%205.17.46%20PM.png)
White truffle mayonnaise by Empire Mayonnaise. $9 at empiremayo.com
![crackcaramel.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/crackcaramel.jpg)
Caramel pops by Crack Caramel. $55 for 27 lollipops at crackcaramel.com
![Screen shot 2012-12-10 at 5.35.43 PM.png](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/Screen%20shot%202012-12-10%20at%205.35.43%20PM.png)
SOUR
Pickles-Every-Month subscription curated by New York Mouth. $200 for six months at newyorkmouth.com
TOMATO-EY
Crushed heirloom tomatoes by Happy Girl Kitchen Co. $8 at happygirlkitchen.com
Homemade marinara sauce from Tommaso's in San Francisco. $7 at taylorsmarket.com.
CRAZY
Ridiculous cookies by Fattycakes NY. $13 for a half-dozen at fattycakesny.com
![SWT.jpg]()
CHEWY
Eggnog salt-water taffy by Salty Road. $6 at thesaltyroad.com
![squirl.jpg]()
YUMMY
Shady Lady tomato jam by Sqirl. $12 at sqirlla.com
Pickles-Every-Month subscription curated by New York Mouth. $200 for six months at newyorkmouth.com
![Screen-shot-2012-12-10-at-5.42.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/Screen-shot-2012-12-10-at-5.42.jpg)
Crushed heirloom tomatoes by Happy Girl Kitchen Co. $8 at happygirlkitchen.com
Homemade marinara sauce from Tommaso's in San Francisco. $7 at taylorsmarket.com.
![Screen-shot-2012-12-10-at-6.27.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/Screen-shot-2012-12-10-at-6.27.jpg)
Ridiculous cookies by Fattycakes NY. $13 for a half-dozen at fattycakesny.com
![SWT.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/SWT.jpg)
CHEWY
Eggnog salt-water taffy by Salty Road. $6 at thesaltyroad.com
![squirl.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/squirl.jpg)
YUMMY
Shady Lady tomato jam by Sqirl. $12 at sqirlla.com
![mikeshot.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/mikeshot.jpg)
Mike's Hot Honey. $8 at mikeshothoney.com
![Screen shot 2012-12-10 at 6.43.47 PM.png](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/Screen%20shot%202012-12-10%20at%206.43.47%20PM.png)
CHOCOLATE RYE
Dark chocolate covered rye crisps by Anna's Daughters' Rye Bread. $14 at annasrye.com
![Screen-shot-2012-12-10-at-6.44_1.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/Screen-shot-2012-12-10-at-6.44_1.jpg)
HIPSTER HOT
Coffee by Handsome Coffee Roasters. $12 at handsomecoffee.com
![zoeturkey.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/zoeturkey.jpg)
Zoe's Premium dog food. $5 at zoespremium.com.
![kvass.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/kvass.jpg)
Beet kvass by the Gefilteria. $7 at Zabar's, 2245 Broadway, New York.
![ketchup.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/ketchup.jpg)
CULT KETCHUP
Tomato ketchup by June Taylor. $13 at junetaylorjams.com
![barrhillgin.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/barrhillgin.jpg)
IN THE SPIRIT
Gin made with raw honey by Caledonia Spirits. $44 at astorwines.com
![Screen shot 2012-12-10 at 6.47.50 PM.png](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/Screen%20shot%202012-12-10%20at%206.47.50%20PM.png)
DIY
Mushroom growing gift pack by the Imaginary Farmer. $22 at theimaginaryfarmer.com
![Screen-shot-2012-12-10-at-6.52.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/Screen-shot-2012-12-10-at-6.52.jpg)
Edible Scrabble pieces by Andie's Specialty Sweets. $55 at andiespecialtysweets
![ducasse.png](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/ducasse.png)
J'Taime New York: 150 Culinary Destinations for Food Lovers by Alain Ducasse. $100.00 wherever books are sold.
![illegalmezcal.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/illegalmezcal.jpg)
Artisanal mezcal by Illegal Mezcal. $46.99 at drinkupny.com
![kittymarshmallow.jpeg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/kittymarshmallow.jpeg)
CHEW
Marshmallows by Kitty Lee Thomas Sweets. $9. KittyLeeThomasSweets.com
![pigmint.jpg](http://www.papermag.com/uploaded_images/pigmint.jpg)
Pigmints by Petite Pig Chocolates. 8 for $12 at petitepigchocolates.com
Above: Candy spectacles by Papa Bubble New York. $15 at Papabubbleny.com
Style assistant: Sebastian Pearlman